Comparing both medical alert systems, both provide excellent service and offer a great range of affordable plans, but which one do we recommend?
<img loading="lazy" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-24745" src="https://tower.top10-medicalalertsystems.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Img-of-sporty-mature-couple-styaing-fit-with-sport.jpg" alt="Img-of-sporty-mature-couple-styaing-fit-with-sport" width="600" height="400" srcset="https://tower.top10-medicalalertsystems.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Img-of-sporty-mature-couple-styaing-fit-with-sport.jpg 600w, https://tower.top10-medicalalertsystems.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Img-of-sporty-mature-couple-styaing-fit-with-sport-768x512.jpg 768w" sizes="(max-width: 600px) 100vw, 600px" />
Medical Care Alert and Medical Guardian are providers of medical alert systems for the older population. Their range of systems is known for quickly connecting senior adults to a responder in times of emergency. In addition, both companies offer contract-free and affordable service coupled with award-winning customer service.
Although there are a lot of similarities between these two names, there are also some distinct features of each company. Keep these in mind when shopping for the right alert system for any loved one. Continue reading to know more about the brands, their services, and how they fare against each other.
<h3>Overview of Medical Care Alert</h3>
A Michigan-based family-owned business, Medical Care Alert provides several choices for medical alert systems to older adults. The subscription rates they offer are also price-locked.
The company was launched in 2008 and outsources monitoring services to a US-based award-winning monitoring center. They are available 24/7 and are staffed with qualified EMT/EMD-certified operators. The monitoring center offers its service to both English and Spanish speakers as well as those who are hard of hearing or deaf.
<h3>Available Medical Alert Systems</h3>
<table>
<tbody>
<tr>
<td width="103">Alert Systems</td>
<td width="108">Monthly Cost</td>
<td width="96">Connection</td>
<td width="96">Type</td>
<td width="235">Best For</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td width="103">Home &amp; Away</td>
<td width="108">$36.62</td>
<td width="96">WiFi, Cellular, GPS</td>
<td width="96">On-the-Go</td>
<td width="235">People who want on-the-go protection or have a caregiver who can track their location</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td width="103">Home</td>
<td width="108">$27.45</td>
<td width="96">Landline</td>
<td width="96">At-Home</td>
<td width="235">People who already have a landline and spend majority of their time at home</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td width="103">Home &amp; Yard</td>
<td width="108">$32.04</td>
<td width="96">Landline/Cellular</td>
<td width="96">At-Home</td>
<td width="235">People who stay at home most of the time but may also be involved in activities outside</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td width="103">Home (4G LTE)</td>
<td width="108">$32.04</td>
<td width="96">Cellular</td>
<td width="96">At-Home</td>
<td width="235">People who stay at home the majority of the time but do not have a landline</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
What We Like:
• Price-locked subscription rates 
• No contracts 
• MT/EMD-certified monitoring team available 24/7 
• Monitoring center supports hard of hearing and deaf customers 
• Back-up battery for in-home system lasts 72 hours 
• Caregiver app 
• SMS feature for caregivers 
• Free shipping
What We Don’t Like:
• No option for monthly payment 
• Substantial savings only through an annual subscription 
• Limited languages supported by the monitoring center
<h3>Overview of Medical Guardian</h3>
Medical Guardian has been providing alert systems for 15 years ad has become one of the leading and highly trusted brands of alert systems. Established in 2006, the company puts customers first and endeavors to help them “live life without limits.” Medical Guardian offers six different medical alert systems that can be used both in-home and on the go. It is also one of the small number of brands that offer a smartwatch option with their systems. The latest product called the Mini Guardian is one of the tiniest devices on the market.
Medical Guardian’s monitoring centers are based in the United States, available 24/7, and are UL listed. There are other features offered such as fall detection, wall-mounted boxes, lockboxes, and more for an extra cost.
<h3>Available Medical Alert Systems</h3>
<table>
<tbody>
<tr>
<td width="103">Alert Systems</td>
<td width="108">Monthly Cost</td>
<td width="96">Connection</td>
<td width="96">Type</td>
<td width="235">Best For</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td width="103">Classic Guardian</td>
<td width="108">$29.95</td>
<td width="96">Landline</td>
<td width="96">In-Home</td>
<td width="235">People who stay at home most of the time and have a landline</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td width="103">Home Guardian</td>
<td width="108">$34.95</td>
<td width="96">Cellular</td>
<td width="96">In-Home</td>
<td width="235">People who stay at home most of the time but without a landline</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td width="103">Active Guardian</td>
<td width="108">$44.95</td>
<td width="96">Cellular, WiFi, and GPS</td>
<td width="96">On-the-Go</td>
<td width="235">People who spend a significant amount of time outdoors and prefer a wearable device with fall detection.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td width="103">Mini Guardian</td>
<td width="108">$39.95, plus $124.95 one-time equipment cost</td>
<td width="96">Cellular, WiFi, and GPS</td>
<td width="96">On-the-Go</td>
<td width="235">People who prefer a compact and discreet device with an unlimited range of coverage plus fall detection.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td width="103">Mobile Guardian</td>
<td width="108">$44.95</td>
<td width="96">Cellular, GPS</td>
<td width="96">On-the-Go</td>
<td width="235">Active users who spend most of their time at home, in their garden, or chatting with a neighbor</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td width="103">MGMove</td>
<td width="108">$44.95, plus one-time $299.95 equipment cost</td>
<td width="96">Cellular, WiFi, and GPS</td>
<td width="96">On-the-Go</td>
<td width="235">Older adults who prefer a stylish smartwatch medical alert for at-home and on-the-go use.</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
What We Like:
• Six device/system options 
• Smartwatch medical alert 
• US-based monitoring center available 24/7 
• Mobile system batteries last up to 7 days 
• No contracts required 
• Voice-activated alerts 
• Caregiver contact 
• Spouse monitoring ( for an additional $2.99 a month)
What We Don’t Like:
• No free trial 
• Certain systems have expensive equipment
<h3>Similarities</h3>
Medical Guardian and Medical Care Alert both offer a range of in-home and on-the-go emergency response systems. The devices are offered without contracts and activation fees. These providers also offer optional features such as fall detection, lockboxes, and spouse coverage. Other similarities include:
• Self-installation 
• Free activation 
• Average response time is less than 45 seconds 
• Wide variety of system options 
• Range of wearable devices, including smartwatch option 
• Fall detection feature 
• Two-way talk capability 
• Customer-friendly return policies 
• 24/7, UL-Certified monitoring centers 
• Highly trained monitoring center employees 
• Wall-mounted help buttons 
• Support multiple users 
• GPS supported devices 
• At-Home landline systems
Alert Systems and Prices
Medical Care Alert
Medical Care Alert offers four different emergency systems. Three are perfect for older adults who like to spend most of their time at home and one is a great service for more active users who often participate in outdoor activities or events. Medical Care Alert’s subscription rates start at $26 and cover the cost of equipment. Emergency buttons are in provided as necklaces, wristbands, and wall buttons. The in-home system base station can connect to an emergency pendant up to 1,000 feet away. The backup battery lasts up to 72 hours. The on-the-go system however requires the batteries to be recharged every three days.
Medical Guardian
Medical Guardian’s emergency buttons for their systems are in the style of wristbands or pendants. A lot of their equipment comes free with a subscription except for the Mini Guardian and MGMove. The Mini Guardian has a one-time charge of $124 for equipment while the MGMove smartwatch requires users to pay an additional $299.95. The in-home systems from Medical Guardian have an estimated range of 350 to 1,300 ft from the base station. The numbers vary depending on the specific system.
Each system also performs a monthly test to ensure that it’s functional. If there are any power interruptions, users can feel safe because each at-home system contains a backup battery that can last 32 hours. The MgMove smartwatch battery can last 48 hours while the Mini and Active Guardian systems have a battery life of up to 7 days.
<h3>Monitoring Centers and Emergency Response</h3>
Medical Care Alert
Medical Care Alert users typically have to wait 25 to 30 seconds after pressing the emergency button to reach an operator at a California or New York monitoring center. The company outsources its monitoring to a central station that is TMA Five Diamond Certified. The two centers on opposite sides of the US allow users to connect to a center even if a region experiences a crisis such as a blackout.
Medical Guardian
When a user presses the emergency button, they are connected to a certified operator in one of Medical Guardian’s 24/7 centers that are TMA Five Diamond Certified. In less than 45 seconds, the user can reach an operator who can help them with the emergency. They will contact the people in the Care Circle or dispatch first responders if needed.
<h3>Conclusion</h3>
Medical Care Alert and Medical Guardian both offer a valuable solution to older adults’ personal safety. Each provider has award-winning monitoring teams and customer support, a great range of systems, and wearable options. It’s not surprising that these two names are some of the most recommended systems.
When it comes to the difference between the two companies, Medical Guardian offers more variety in systems and a more familiar brand. It also provides for users who may have style preferences or want something discreet. Medical Care, meanwhile, offers slightly lower systems with rates that are price locked, a free trial for 14 days, and an app for caregivers to track their wards.
Both Medical Care Alert and Medical Guardian offer services that are contract-free which means the risk is minimal whichever name you go with.

Img-of-Happy-two-generations-male-family-old-senior-mature-father-and-smiling-young-adult-grown-son-enjoying-talking-having-friendly-positive-conversation-sit-on-sofa-at-home

A Comprehensive Guide To Buying Medical Alert Systems

Portrait-of-beautiful-senior-couple-hugging-in-the-summer-park

Differences Between A Mobile And At Home Medical Alert System

Medical Care Alert Vs Medical Guardian

Compare the Best 

Alternatives  to

 Mobile Help

Compare the Best Alternatives to Mobile Help

Top 10 Emergency

Alert Systems

Top 10 Emergency Alert Systems

Top 10 Lifeline

Programs for {year}

Top 10 Lifeline Programs for {year}

Top 10

Best Life Alerts

of {year}

Top 10 Best Life Alerts of {year}

Compare the Best Life Alert Systems

 Covered by Medicare

Compare the Best Life Alert Systems Covered by Medicare

Top 10 Monitoring

Systems for seniors

Top 10 Monitoring Systems for seniors

Top 10 Fall Alert 

Systems of {year}

Top 10 Fall Alert Systems of {year}

Top 10 Medical Alert

for Seniors

Top 10 Medical Alert for Seniors

Top 10 Health Alert

Devices of 2023

Top 10 Health Alert Devices Of {year}

Top 10 Wireless

Medical Alert

Top 10 Wireless Medical Alert of {year}

Top 10 Medical

Alert Bracelets

Top 10 Medical Alert Bracelets of {year}

Top 10

Medical Alert Devices

Top 10 Medical Alert Devices of {year}

Top 10

Medical Alert jewelry

Top 10 Medical Alert jewelry of {year}

Top 10

Medical Alert Bracelets

Top 10 Medical Alert Bracelets

Top 10 Medical 

Alert Necklaces

Top 10 Medical Alert Necklaces for Seniors

Top 10 Best

Fall Alert Systems

of 2022

Top 10 Best Fall Alert Systems of 2022

{year}'s Top Medical Guardian Alternatives

{year}'s Top Medical Guardian 
Alternatives

Top10MedicalAlertSystems.com is an independent review and comparison website funded by referral fees. We may be paid compensation when you user buy a Medical Alert System through our website links. This does not affect our reviews and ratings which are based on thousands of ratings and testing our team made. We regularly review new Medical Alert System services but do not feature every Medical Alert System product on the market due to high amount of companies.

We receive advertising fees from the companies listed in the chart below, which affect rankings

Navigate

Must Reads

Top 10 Medical Alert Systems